Opinion: Why Bittensor is a Scam, and TAO is Heading Towards Zero?

By: blockbeats|2025/04/18 03:30:04
Share
copy
Original Author: WeirdMind

Starting a long post to document my thoughts: Why is #Bittensor a scam, and $TAO is heading to zero?

First of all, although Bittensor has always touted itself as a "fair mining" project, the underlying Subtensor is neither a PoW chain nor a PoS chain; it is a single-chain network managed by the Opentensor Foundation (Bittensor's foundation), with a very opaque mechanism.

As for the so-called "Triumvirate + Senate" binary governance structure, the triumvirate consists of three Opentensor Foundation employees, and the Senate consists of the top 12 ranked validation nodes, all of whom are insiders or stakeholders.

Opinion: Why Bittensor is a Scam, and TAO is Heading Towards Zero?

Secondly, on January 3, 2021, the "Kusanagi" release marked the activation of the Bittensor network, allowing miners and validators to start receiving the first batch of TAO rewards. From network activation to the launch of the subnet on October 2, 2023, a total of 5.38 million TAO have been mined by Bittensor in the 2 years and 9 months. However, there is no documentation or information indicating how the tokens generated during the period from January 3, 2021, to October 2, 2023, when the subnet went live, were distributed according to what rules and where they ultimately ended up.

It can be reasonably speculated that these tokens were divided among internal members and interest groups because, unlike Bitcoin, Bittensor was hatched and invested by VCs.

If you take this portion of the tokens and divide it by the current circulation of 8.61 million, at least 62.5% of TAO is in the hands of internal members and interest groups. Furthermore, the Opentensor Foundation and some VC investors also operate validation node businesses on Bittensor, so the percentage of chips in their hands will only be higher than this 62.5% figure.

Similar to the recent Avalanche of OM a few days ago, all projects with an inexplicably high market cap, their distorted market cap is often due to poor circulation.

Billions market cap backed by poor liquidity.

The following chart illustrates the historical staking status of TAO. Don't be fooled into thinking that TAO's staking rate has gradually increased from low to high. The reason it is depicted this way is due to TAO's intense inflation.

In reality, TAO's staking rate has never been below 70%, reaching close to 90% at its highest. Based on TAO's current market cap of 2 billion USD, it means that at least 1.4 billion USD worth of TAO has never entered circulation. The actual market cap of TAO is around 600 million USD, with a corresponding FDV of up to 5 billion USD, a typical project with low circulation and high market cap.

The so-called AI project ranked first by market cap, how its bubble was inflated by whales, is worth pondering.

Lastly, the so-called dTAO upgrade is more like providing OGs with an opportunity to exit liquidity. It allows you to buy subnetwork tokens with high leverage and take over the TAO held by the vested interests.

According to the three-disc theory, Bittensor's dTAO upgrade in February of this year introduced new Ponzi scheme models, the "Split Disc" and the "Mutual Aid Disc," in a situation where the "Bonus Disc" was no longer sustainable. The core purpose is to leverage down in a weakening old narrative and an external liquidity almost squeezed dry by fabricating a new narrative to attract new external liquidity.

First is the "Split Disc": By allowing all subnets to issue tokens, TAO has successfully positioned itself as the base currency for all Bittensor subnet tokens, whose value is supported by tokens from several dozen (and increasingly more) subnets.

Due to differences in the depth of trading pools, subnet tokens often experience astonishing price surges. With this, Bittensor has showcased to the outside world a disguised eco-system that offers high ROI opportunities. The exaggerated nominal ROI provided by Subnet Alpha tokens artificially created significant buying pressure for TAO and acted as a camouflage for the root network validation nodes' TAO sell-off.

Unfortunately, due to Bittensor's closed ecosystem and the market transition from bull to bear, the dTAO upgrade failed to attract sufficient external liquidity, and even internal liquidity (those staked in the root network) was not adequately mobilized and activated.

Simultaneously, the lowered entry barriers and unlimited token issuance for subnets have excessively diluted the overall liquidity of Bittensor's already limited ecosystem.

Second is the "Mutual Aid Disc." Unfortunately, Bittensor's subnet token issuance does not establish a highly circulating mutual-aid model as seen in Pump.fun on Solana, as Bittensor's network infrastructure is very poor, and even different subnet tokens cannot be exchanged, making it difficult for subnet token participants to migrate liquidity between different subnets. This further exacerbates the liquidity dilution issue brought about by a high split ratio, preventing funds from remaining engaged in the ecosystem for continuous speculation.

Once the whales of the root network start collectively fleeing, both on-chain and off-chain liquidity will quickly dry up.

The moment you sell, game over.

So are the whales fleeing? The answer is "they are fleeing"!

Since the launch of dTAO:

➤ The Bittensor protocol injected 450,000 TAO into the subnet pool

➤ 150,000 TAO (33%) flowed to the root network validation nodes through an "automatic sell-off" mechanism

➤ The root network staking amount (τ₀) decreased by 150,000 TAO (5,860,000 → 5,710,000)

This means:

300,000 TAO (≈70 million USD) successfully fled from the root network and may be liquidated on a CEX.

Moreover, Bittensor's base before was the subnet and miners. Bittensor's previous pattern was like a VC, providing funds to projects to focus on building a valuable business model first without immediately worrying about making money to ensure a balance of income and expenditure. This is the core reason why projects are attracted to build subnets on Bittensor.

Projects attracted to Bittensor brought miners who provide computing power (in Bittensor's terms, "intelligence"). This "you scratch my back, I scratch yours" situation is the core reason why Bittensor could become the leading cryptocurrency AI project by market capitalization.

However, after the dTAO upgrade, the interests of subnet projects, miners, and validation nodes are no longer aligned, and the previous mutual benefit scenario is no more. The dTAO model does not bring any benefits to subnet projects, and the collapse of the economic model is currently the biggest and most fundamental problem for Bittensor.

In Bittensor's dTAO model, the Subnet Alpha token is a kind of "voucher" we receive for staking TAO in the subnet, not a Token that can circulate in the general sense. This makes it difficult for subnet projects to invent any effective Tokenomics for these tokens. Besides being able to mint more Alpha tokens, these Alpha tokens have no utility for retail holders. From what I have observed, the most common way subnet projects are trying to pump the token price now is by announcing that project revenue will be used to buy back Alpha tokens, for example, Chutes (SN64).

However, if the Subnet Owner can only empower the Alpha token in this way, then the funny thing happens. The 18% Alpha tokens dTAO allocated to the Subnet project will forever stay in the hands of the project itself. After all, if you have announced a buyback of tokens using project revenue, why would you sell your own tokens?

Selling and buying back are contradictory.

Therefore, not only can the Subnet Owner not receive any income from the dTAO model, but they even have to subsidize it: create external revenue and inject it into their Subnet's Alpha tokens. This means that Subnet projects and miners are essentially working for the validators. Validators, as the privileged class of the Bittensor network, not only cannot do anything of value but can continuously sell Subnet Alpha tokens from the start of the dTAO upgrade, with up to 1/3 of the daily emission flowing back to the root network's TAO.

The reason Bittensor can attract other projects to build Subnets on top of them is fundamentally because the previous TAO emission was a good subsidy mechanism for emerging projects without income, allowing these projects to focus solely on their operational models that needed to be run.

If not only does this subsidy mechanism disappear, but it even reverses, then why would Subnet projects still want to build Subnets on Bittensor? Going solo, keeping all the income for themselves, isn't that better?

Therefore, the dTAO model, as a means for interest groups to dump their holdings, is harming the foundation of Bittensor's development to date. Although most of the Subnet business models in the Bittensor ecosystem are a mess that can't even be looked at, without them, Bittensor would also lose its last fig leaf.

References:  
1. Bittensor Official Documentation: docs.bittensor.com
2. Report by @harry_xymeng "Bittensor: When the Music Stops": prism-pancake-61a.notion.site/Bittensor-432c…
3. Guide by @thecryptoskanda "The Three Pan Principle - The Ultimate Guide to Ponzi Construction": x.com/thecryptoskand…

Original Article Link

You may also like

a16z Leads $18M Seed Round for Catena Labs, Crypto Industry Bets on Stablecoin AI Payment

Traditional finance is still stuck in a "human-to-human" model, while Catena aims to achieve "AI-to-AI" interaction.

Pharos, deeply integrated with AntChain, is about to launch. How can we get involved?

What is the relationship between the $8 million funded NewChain and Ant, and how will they interact?

The End and Rebirth of NFTs: How the Meme Coin Craze Ended the PFP Era?

There must be another Labubu hidden beneath the ruins.

Key Market Intelligence on May 14th, how much did you miss out on?

Featured News


1.Binance Alpha Launches HIPPO, BLUE, and Other Tokens

2.Believe Ecosystem Tokens See General Rise, LAUNCHCOIN Surges Over 250% in 24 Hours

3.Tiger Securities Introduces Cryptocurrency Deposit and Withdrawal Service, Supports Mainstream Cryptocurrencies such as BTC and ETH

4.Current Bitcoin Rally Possibly Driven by Institutions, Retail Traders Yet to Join

5.Binance Wallet's New TGE Privasea AI Participation Requires a 198 Point Threshold, with a Point Consumption of 15


Trending Topics


Source: Overheard on CT (tg: @overheardonct), Kaito


PUMP: Today's discussions about PUMP focus on its new creator revenue-sharing model: the platform will allocate 50% of PumpSwap revenue to token creators, sparking varied reactions from users. Some criticize the move as insufficient or even misleading, while others view it as a positive step the platform is taking to reward creators. Meanwhile, PUMP faces market pressure from emerging competitors like LetsBONKfun and Raydium, which are rapidly gaining market share. Users also express concerns about PUMP's sustainability and potential regulatory risks in the U.S., with discussions extending to the platform's impact on the entire memecoin ecosystem.


COINBASE: Today, Coinbase became the first crypto company to join the S&P 500 Index, replacing Discover Financial Services, sparking widespread industry attention. The entire crypto community views this milestone as a significant development, signaling that crypto assets are further integrating into the mainstream financial system. The news has sparked lively discussions on Twitter, with many users pointing out that this may attract more institutional investors to enter the Bitcoin and other cryptocurrency markets.


XRP: XRP became the focal point of today's crypto discussion, with its significant market movements and strategic advances drawing attention. XRP has surpassed USDT to become the third-largest cryptocurrency by market capitalization, sparking market excitement and discussions about its future potential. The surge in market capitalization and price is believed to be related to increasing institutional interest, deepening strategic partnerships, and its role in the crypto ecosystem. Additionally, XRP's integration into multiple financial systems and its potential as a macro asset class are also seen as key factors driving the current market sentiment.


DYDX: Today's discussions about DYDX mainly focused on the dYdX Yapper Leaderboard launched by KaitoAI. The leaderboard aims to identify the most active community participants, with a total of $150,000 in rewards to be distributed over the first three seasons. This initiative has sparked broad community participation, with many users discussing the potential rewards and the incentive effect on the DYDX ecosystem. Meanwhile, progress on the ethDYDX to dYdX native chain migration and historical airdrop events have also been topics of discussion.


Featured Articles


1. "What Is 'ICM'? Holding Up the $4 Billion Market Cap Solana's New Narrative"

Overnight, the hottest narrative in the crypto space has become "Internet Capital Markets," with a host of crypto projects and founders, led by the Solana ecosystem's new Launchpad platform Believe, releasing this phrase. Together with "Believe in something," it has become the new slogan heralding the onset of a bull market. What exactly is the so-called "Internet Capital Market," will it become a short-lived hype phrase like the Base ecosystem's previous Content Coin, and what related targets are available for selection?


2.《LaunchCoin Surges 20x in One Day, How Did Believe Create a $200M Market Cap Shiba Inu After Going to Zero?|100x Retrospective》

LAUNCHCOIN broke through a $200 million market cap today, with the long-lost liquidity and such a high market cap "Memecoin" almost bringing half of the on-chain crypto community CT into the fray. The community is crazily discussing this token, with half of it being FOMO and the other half being FUD. This token, originally issued by Believe founder Ben Pasternak under his personal identity, transformed into a new platform token after a renaming. From once going to zero to a $200 million market cap, what happened in between?


On-chain Data


May 14 On-chain Fund Flow


Within 24 hours, GOONC's market cap soared to 70 million, could GOONC be the next billion-dollar dog on the Believe platform?

Bitcoin has broken $100,000, Ethereum has surpassed 2500, and is Solana's hot streak about to make a comeback?


The current market is in a state of macro euphoria, with GOONC riding the wave today, skyrocketing 10x in just a few hours, reaching a market cap of tens of millions of dollars, trading volume soaring past 50 million, and rumors swirling that the developer may be from OpenAI (unconfirmed but intriguing enough).


The "gooning" Culture in Forums


A ludicrous and absurd Solana meme that some actually buy into.


GOONC is a meme coin that has sprouted from the "gooning" subculture, offering no technological innovation or practical use, its sole function being speculation.


It takes inspiration from an NSFW term "gooning," which refers to a person being deeply immersed in certain content (you know what), eventually entering a nearly religious-like trance.


In Reddit (such as r/GOONED, r/GoonCaves) and some counterculture media outlets (such as MEL Magazine in 2020), "gooning" has gradually transitioned from an adult label to a meme-addicted, digital content and virtual self-indulgence synonym, arguably the epitome of Degen spirit.


GOONC is playing around with this concept, packaging the addictive nature, uselessness, and irony of gooning into a tradable financial product. The project team has made it clear: "We do not solve blockchain problems, we only trade absurdity." Blunt but oddly genuine.


GOONC launched on May 13, 2025, using the meme coin launch platform Believe App's LaunchCoin module on Solana. This tool is highly Degen: zero technical barriers, a few clicks to create a coin, perfect for projects like GOONC that can come up with ideas out of the blue.



The mastermind behind GOONC is also quite something and is the most talked-about, with KOL @basedalexandoor on X platform (alias "Pata van Goon") personally involved. His profile even caught the attention of Marc Andreessen, co-founder of a16z, making onlookers unable to resist speculating if GOONC has a hint of OpenAI lineage.



While this 'OpenAI Endorsement' is currently just community speculation, it is definitely a good card to play to fuel hype. Saying "we are pure speculation" on one hand, while tagging a few "AI + a16z" on the other.


From Wasteland to Moon in One Night


GOONC took off as soon as it launched. After its launch on May 13, 2025, its market capitalization skyrocketed to $22 million within 4 hours, with a trading volume exceeding $25.6 million in 24 hours. According to platform data, the first day of trading saw an astonishing +41,100% surge, soaring from $0.0000001 to $0.02, becoming a "missed-the-boat" situation.


GOONC quickly formed an active trading community post-launch, with a lot of discussion and trading signals appearing on X platform (such as the 292x return signal provided by DeBot). Liquidity pools on exchanges like Raydium and Meteora grew rapidly, supporting high trading volumes and price increases.


The real climax occurred between May 13 and May 14, with the market cap rising to $5.5 million in the morning and directly surpassing $55 million in the afternoon. By the 14th, it briefly approached a $70 million market cap, with the trading volume soaring to $59 million. Some community members even posted screenshots claiming an increase of +85,000%, creating a new myth out of the ruins.


As of 1:30 pm on May 14, the price stabilized around $0.039, with a total market cap and FDV both around $39.6 million, and a 24-hour trading volume of $5.43 million. Active platforms include XT.COM, LBank, Meteora, and others.


Although there was a slight pullback from the peak ($0.07), the coin's popularity remains strong. For a coin that relies purely on "irony + community + X post" to thrive, this performance is already at a stellar level.



Currently, the background of the token's development team is not transparent, increasing the potential risk of a rug pull. Rugcheck.xyz warns that the creator of the GOONC contract may have permission to modify the contract (e.g., change fees or mint additional tokens), posing certain security risks.


Community members speculate that the meteoric rise of GOONC may be the "last hurrah".


How to Get Rich in Crypto Without Relying on Luck? Financial Veteran Raoul Pal's Macro Insights and Investment Path

2008 Financial Crisis "Oracle" Raoul Pal on Cryptocurrency, Resilient Wealth, and Macro Insights.

Popular coins

Latest Crypto News

Read more